State insurance regulators are on the front lines of climate-related natural catastrophe preparedness and response, protecting policyholders and maintaining well-functioning insurance markets.
The ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½, which brings together state insurance regulators, has long been committed to monitoring and addressing how climate-related risks affect policyholders and the insurance industry. There’s critical work being done in every state, and it’s an issue that continues to change rapidly. Our insurance regulatory system is accustomed to adapting to an evolving risk landscape and is well-positioned to address the challenges presented by climate-related risks both today and in the future.
For more than 150 years, from the first fire insurance policies influencing building codes to today’s record-breaking natural catastrophes driving population shifts, state insurance regulators have experience and insight into the impact of climate-related risk on insurance and consumers.
Federal, state, and local stakeholders need to work collaboratively toward mitigation goals. State officials need access to hazard and vulnerability data to identify and address risk characteristics of the local area. Many, but not all, states have Chief Resilience Offices. All states have State Hazard Mitigation Officers. State departments can take an active role in working with federal, state, and local agencies to develop and implement hazard mitigation plans as well as implement policy, legislative, and regulatory actions to support mitigation and resilience.
Ways to get involved:
Various federal and state agencies contribute to mitigation and resiliency. The provides access to regional and local experts across the nation available to assist in climate resilience.
Resilience partners include:
- State Resilience Officers
- State and Local Emergency Managers
- Building Code Enforcement Officials
- Fire Departments/Districts
- Floodplain Managers
- Parks and Recreation Managers
- Planning and Community Development Officials
- Public Information Officers
- Public Works Departments
- Stormwater Managers
- Transportation Officials
- Regional Planning Agencies
- City Councils/Board of Commissions
- Planning Commissions
- Planning and Community Development Planners
- Non-profit Disaster Safety and Recovery Organizations
- Local Business Leaders
In 2021, California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara between the California Department of Insurance and Governor Gavin Newsom’s Administration, including the Governor's Office of Emergency Services (CalOES), the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE), the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research (OPR), and the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to establish consistent statewide standards for home and community hardening that will reduce wildfire risk, protect lives and property, and help make insurance available and affordable to residents and businesses.
The Maryland Insurance Administration is a member of the , hosted by the Maryland Department of the Environment. Members of the group include organizations, academic institutions, energy providers, and state and local government agencies.
The role of the Chief Resilience Office (CRO) is typically created by executive order or legislative action. CROs can be situated in governor's offices, environmental agencies or public safety agencies. For background information on the emergence of Chief Resilience Officers and what states have them, see
Even if your state doesn't have a resilience office, there are key stakeholders that need to collaborate on resilience. Smart Growth America produced a guidebook, . If you're not sure where to start, a good place would be contacting your state hazard mitigation officer.
State Hazard Mitigation Officers are responsible for creating state Hazard Mitigation Plans. Plans are often a joint effort between multiple agencies and state offices. State department of insurance personnel can get involved in the coordination and planning. The Federal Emergency Management Agency provides a list of state emergency managers with contact information here:
FEMA also provides a Guide to Hazard Mitigation Plans:
Engaging stakeholders through a comprehensive hazard mitigation plan and strategy helps prepare communities to be more resilient. FEMA resource guides facilitate and development of state . State Departments of Insurance can be part of the team to complete emergency planning documents. The Nebraska Department of Insurance collaborated with states officials to develop their state emergency management planning report in 2020. FEMA provides a to identify the agency/agencies responsible for coordinating development of Hazard Mitigation Plans as well as the current status.
Hazard Mitigation Officers are connected through organizations such as the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the . NEMA fosters partnerships and initiatives to improve the nation's emergency management, homeland security and public safety capabilities.
The Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency provides an assessment of critical infrastructure to assess current resilience and potential improvements. The process usually takes about a year to collect and analyze data on the critical infrastructure in a designated area and could be a valuable tool in hazard mitigation planning.
is a website designed to help guide through the process of developing or updating a local hazard mitigation plan that will meet the requirements for approval by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). The website offers practical approaches and examples for how communities can engage in effective planning to reduce long-term risk from natural disasters. These examples of best practices were curated from some of the best local hazard mitigation plans in the U.S.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency consists of ten regions in the continental United States and territories. Regional coordinators and state insurance departments need to coordinate after disasters happen but they should start communicating during blue skies to share resources and coordinate on risk mitigation. To find out which region your state is in and the contact information for FEMA regional leaders visit
Participate in the ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½/Federal Emergency Management Agency (C) Advisory Group and ask ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½ staff about FEMA regional workshops /cmte_c_fema.htm
FEMA resources and recordings of prior regional workshops are available on the Catastrophe Resource Center.
After assembling the team of experts, you need defined objectives and an action plan. The U.S. Climate Resilience Toolkit provides a framework, Steps for Resilience, with case studies, tools, and resources by region.
Community level risk assessment begins with identifying hazards common to the local area and how the event could impact the community. Several federal resources are available to help communities identify their risk.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) provides GIS mapping tools to identify the level of risk from natural hazards, vulnerable populations and resilience indicators by region.
- The National Risk Index identifies communities at risk for 18 natural hazards. It visualizes natural hazard risk metrics and includes data about expected annual losses from natural hazards, social vulnerability and community resilience.
- The Resilience Analysis and Planning Tool (RAPT) provides access to data and GIS mapping which includes community resilience indicators, current and historical seismic and weather-related events, sea level rise predictions and equity considerations.
Several states also have risk assessment tools available for the hazards most common to their local area.
In Oregon, required the Oregon Department of Forestry (ODF) to produce a .
Colorado Forest Atlas also provides a to increase wildfire awareness across the state.
To understand how disclosure can change consumer buying behaviors, go to the "Consumer Outreach" tab.
The following visual aid, provided by shows the steps for identifying, assessing, and analyzing natural catastrophe risk.
Where and how we build is critical for community resilience. Building in hazardous regions, without contemplating the need for resilience leaves people and properties vulnerable to disruption. Thoughtful land use and construction design goes a long way in preventing damage from natural perils. When hazards have been identified, the local community should plan and build accordingly. According to the National Institute for Building Sciences (NIBS), there are measures that communities, local governments, land owners, developers, and tenants can take to reduce the impact of natural hazards. NIBS shows that adopting and enforcing current model codes saves $11 per $1 spent.
In November 2020, FEMA released a report, evaluating buildings constructed between 2000 and 2016 to analyze the potential losses avoided from flood, hurricane wind, and earthquake by building to code. The study evaluated losses avoided and concluded that building codes not only reduce potential property loss, there are numerous cascading benefits.
Following the work of the study, FEMA developed a to prioritize the advancement and enforcement of hazard-resistant building codes and produced a in addition to a .
In addition to building codes, local governments develop land-use laws and zoning restrictions to determine where and how people develop. Integrating risk identification and assessment into thoughtful land use planning can limit building in high risk areas and ensure that buildings are designed and constructed to better withstand perils common to the area.
Ways to get involved:
The International Code Council is the largest international association of building safety professionals, offering solutions dedicated to providing businesses and municipalities with necessary tools to build safe, affordable and sustainable communities.
The International Code Council (ICC) family of solutions includes developing codes and standards, product testing and evaluation, accreditation, software and technology, professional developing and training, and consulting services.
ICC develops model codes on a three year cycle. To find out what building codes have been adopted in your state, check out . Make sure to select your state and click on "state information and resources" to find out what codes have been adopted as well as the state agencies responsible for code adoption locally.
Special building codes, called International Wildland Urban Interface Codes (IWUI), exist to make properties more resilient to wildfire. More than 46 million residences located in 70,000 communities throughout the U.S. are at risk from wildfires. The 2019 NIBS study found that implementing the ICC's 2015 International Wildland Urban Interface Code (IWUIC) saves $4 for every $1 invested. Learn more about IWUI codes here:
In March 2013, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) released its .
FEMA also developed a course in 2022, .
Building codes are updated on a three-year cycle. Code adoption resources and a toolkit are available here:
Nature-based solutions promote resilience by using the natural landscape as a buffer from extreme weather risk. Solutions can be designed to improve water quality, reduce flood risk, and limit coastal erosion. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) provides .
Verisk's Building Code Effectiveness Grading Schedule (BCEGS®) assesses community building codes and their enforcement, with special emphasis on mitigation of losses from natural hazards.
The BCEGS program assesses a community’s building code enforcement in three areas:
Code administration
Plan review
Field inspection
Identify your state/territory BCEGS score here:
In some areas, insurers may restrict coverage based on the risk characteristics of the region and/or require buildings be constructed to minimum standards to withstand common perils.
The BuildStrong Coalition is a group of firefighters, emergency responders, insurers, engineers, architects, contractors and manufacturers, as well as consumer organizations, code specialists, and others organized to increase investment in mitigation.
Mitigating property losses and reducing disruption to the community positively impacts consumers, businesses, insurers and local economies. Construction standards are great for new buildings but most of our building stock already exists so learning to retrofit properties to withstand hazards is essential. According to the National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS) , private-sector building retrofits save $4 per $1 spent.1 Additionally, loss after disaster takes shape in many forms. In addition to property damage, there are losses from business closings, lost time and wages, and disruptions to public services including schools and hospitals.
Following major disasters, state, federal and local resources are spent to aid in recovery. Ensuring that buildings and infrastructure are built to withstand common hazards in the region can reduce the economic impact to local communities, saving time and money to the broader economy.
Ways to get involved:
The IBHS was formed by the property casualty insurance industry in 1977 to help coordinate property insurance plans. In 2010, the IBHS Research Center was established to advance the scientific understanding of natural hazards and their impact on the built environment.
IBHS Fortified Construction Standards go beyond typical building codes to deliver superior performance to improve a properties performance to withstand the impact of severe weather events including hurricane force wind and wind-driven rain, thunderstorm and lower-level tornadoes.
To see how many homes in your state have been constructed to the FORTIFIED standard, check out this map: .
Smart Home America provides a directory of IBHS FORTIFIED evaluators, contractors, builders, roofers, and inspectors: .
Wildfire Prepared Home is a voluntary, research-based program with tips to meaningfully reduce a home's likelihood of being devastated by wildfire.
The National Flood Insurance Protection System (NFIP) developed a to identify floodplain management activities to reduce a communities flood risk. The is a cooperative agreement that provides funding to states to support NFIP communities in implementing floodplain management activities.
The National Fire Protection Agency (NFPA), co-sponsored by the USDA Forest Service and the National Association of State Foresters, administers Firewise USA. Firewise USA is a recognition program with a collaborative framework to help neighbors in a geographic area organize and take action to reduce their risk of property loss due to wildfire.
California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara directed the Department to write a new regulation requiring insurance companies to submit rate filings incorporating wildfire safety standards created by the Department, and to establish a process for releasing wildfire risk determinations to residents and businesses. A list of insurers offering discounts is provided for transparency on a .
for homes that meet the FORTIFIED Standard.
Mississippi offers a catastrophe savings account and IBHS FORTIFIED and BCEGS discounts on property insurance as well as a special endorsement for roof replacement.
Mitigation discounts are offered in multiple states based on home hardening efforts undertaken by property-owners and communities.
Alabama's mitigation grant funding program, created through legislation, includes $10 million in annual funding from the insurance industry.Ìý
ÌýPublic-private partnerships can be used to fund mitigation and improve resilience to weather-related events. Zurich Z Foundation teamed up with Resilient Cities Network to identify neighborhoods, convene community and government partners, and deploy a Resilient Community Impact Fund (RCIFund) to direct investment into improving community resilience from weather-related events. The ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½'s Climate and Resiliency Task Force heard about the partnership during the 2022 Spring National Meeting, more information is available in the meeting minutes. Link to video describing the partnershipÌý.Ìý
Munich Re worked with The Nature Conservancy and the US Corp of Engineers to develop a study to identify a nature-based solution to reduce flood risk in the central U.S. and combined with community-based insurance, can significantly drive down the cost of flood insurance for local residents.ÌýÌý
The perceived costs of implementing mitigation projects and/or lack of return on their investment are primary reasons consumers do not fortify their homes (Journal of Insurance Regulation, Public Policy and Regulation to Reduce Underlying Risks, 2015, p. 6). Non-insurance policy measures have more potential to create immediate and easily measurable cost savings (via grants, loans, tax deduction-credits, etc.) than do insurance policy measures (Journal of Insurance Regulation, State and Local Policy Instruments for the Promotion of Catastrophe Mitigation, 2017, p.4). The National Institute for Building Sciences released a white paper in Oct. 2015, , which concludes that the most cost-effective manner to achieve resilience is through a holistic and integrated set of public, private and hybrid programs based on capturing opportunities available through mortgages and loans; insurance; finance; tax incentives and credits; grants; regulations; and enhanced building codes and their application.
There are several organizations established to help connect communities with access to resilience funding. Given the scope of options and their varied requirements, understanding the landscape can be a challenge.
The American Society of Adaptation Professionals has developed a to guide governmental organizations through the process of obtaining resilience funding.
Ways to get involved:
A fundamental barrier to mitigation is the cost. Resilience grants can relieve the financial burden. Benefit-cost studies are an essential first step for most public grants. The Mississippi Insurance Department led a , completed in Feb. 2010.
Visit to search for grants, understand the lifecycle of the grant process and get access to tools and resources for applying.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) offers multiple grant programs, each requiring applicants and recipients to use various tools to apply for and manage their grants. The required tools and guide to resources available are provided on their website at fema.gov/grants/tools.
Immediately after a disaster, FEMA, the U.S. Small Business Administration, and other government agencies offer initial assistance. HUD then provides additional support for ongoing recovery through programs and partnerships.
The provides Community Development Block Grant Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR) funds to help cities, counties, and states recover from Presidentially declared disasters.
helps rural residents, businesses, and communities impacted by disasters and supports long-term planning and recovery efforts.
provides low-interest disaster loans to help businesses and homeowners recover from declared disasters.
Zurich North America with the Resilient Cities Network and deploy a . The RCIFunds platform leverages funding sources across local and global institutions to improve community resilience. to the fund.
, a parametric InsurTech company. FloodFlash is based in the UK providing a product with quick payout for flooding events.
The American Council of Life Insurers (ACLI) established to develop an impact investing initiative for life insurance companies to strengthen communities through affordable, sustainable housing.
offer tailored resources and innovative programs that invest federal dollars alongside private sector capital, supporting economically disadvantaged communities.
is one of the largest CDFIs that invests in and advocates for preservation and development of affordable housing. Their initiative provides support to help affordable housing owners in Miami, Orlando and Tampa.
The provides , including research to support resilience and disaster response.
Several states have worked with the to obtain grant funding for research related to the health impacts of natural catastrophe disaster events.
State Mitigation Grant Programs, designed to help consumer reduce their risk of property loss. The structure of the programs differ but they all share a common purpose of making properties safer, keeping people in their homes and reducing the disruption to local communities and economies caused by severe weather events.Ìý
The provides grants to Alabama residents for residential wind mitigation on existing owner-occupied, single family homes.Ìý
The California Earthquake Authority (CEA) helps homeowners lessen the potential for damage during an earthquake through funding low-cost retrofits for single family dwellings.Ìý
provides free home inspections and a matching grant program to help homeowners retrofit properties making them less vulnerable to hurricane damage.Ìý
Louisiana Fortify Homes Program authorizes the insurance commissioner to make grants to retrofit roofs of insurance property using the IBHS fortified standards.
The program offers grants to help eligible policyholders in beach communities better protect their homes against the threat of hurricanes.Ìý
The program provides matching and non-matching grant funds to help property owners retrofit their homes to make them more resistant to damage from hurricane and high-wind.ÌýÌý
Ìý
Consumers and communities need to understand their risks in order to make informed choices and manage their risks effectively. With the growing availability of risk-related data, insurers may have access to more or different risk information about a property than the property owner. This creates an provides an opportunity to help consumers understand and manage their risk more effectively. Even when consumers have access to risk information, they may choose to accept or transfer it, rather than mitigate, for various reasons. In a 2020 ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½ Survey of homeowners only 41% of policyholders believed that weather events affected the risk of future losses to their homes or property.
Ways to get involved:
The ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½ PIO Resource Center provides information and a forum for state insurance regulators to share content, resources and information on consumer outreach. Regulators can request access to the PIO Resource Center by emailing .
The Center for Policy and Research produced a State Resiliency Map providing disaster resilience information available from each state insurance department.
Below are a few examples of consumer campaigns developed by State Insurance Departments:
provides tips to help consumers prepare for tornadoes, floods, wildfires, wind and hail, earthquakes and winter storms.
Missouri Storm Aware provides storms facts and video content to help consumers be aware of their tornado and flood risk and know what to when storms occur.
The campaign was established to build alliances throughout the state and spread the message about mitigation opportunities as well as provide outreach and education to consumers.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) maintains providing consumers with tips and resources to prepare for whatever weather they may encounter in their region of the country. There's even a mobile app to get preparedness strategies and real-time weather and emergency alerts.
The ²»Á¼Ñо¿Ëù¹Ù·½ produces consumer outreach to help people navigate insurance issues and prepare for weather-related events. The What the Flood campaign was created to help people understand the types of water-related damages not covered by a standard homeowners policy. Go-Bag Disaster Prep was developed to help people prepare for natural disasters. The Home Inventory Mobile App was created for consumers to track personal items in case they incur a loss and must submit a list of recoverable items to file a claim. The Consumer Resource Center provides tools and resources to help consumers understand different types of insurance, claims processes, and practical tips. Consumer assistance resources are also available on the Catastrophe Resource Center.
(UP) provides consumers with information on buying and understanding insurance coverage, navigating claims, identifying fraud, and aiding in recovery. UP developed a to help renters, home and small business owners take specific steps to protect their assets and build financial safety nets for disaster resiliency. Following severe wildfire loss events, UP started the to reduce wildfire risk and help restore affordable, available property insurance options for home and business owners in California.
The (FLASH) produces tools and media toolkits to encourage people to prepare ahead of storm season, , and . FLASH also develops campaigns including to help people understand the importance of building codes and how to find out the construction codes for their own property.
The (IBHS) provides tips for home and business owners to prepare for weather-related loss events.
The University of Alabama conducted a study and found that FORTIFIED properties sold for nearly 7% more than those built to conventional construction standards.Ìý
The University of Alabama conducted a standard and found that the combined effect of lower insurance costs due to reduced risk as well as increased revenue for the property, resulted in increased returns between 8% for inland properties with added hail protection to 72% for coastal properties built to the FORTIFIED gold standard.
In July 2022, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) released a paper, Flood Risk Disclosure: Model State Requirements for Disclosing Flood Risk During Real Estate Transactions. The paper includes detail on state laws requiring flood disclosure as well as the relationship between state flood risk disclosure requirements and flood insurance penetration rates.Ìý
Redfin provides a platform for people to search for homes to buy. In 2021, they began listing property flood risks based on information from First Street Foundation and FEMA. In Sept. 2022, they published the findings from a research project to identify how consumer buying behaviors changed based on the additional information available regarding the property's flood risk. show that users who viewed homes with severe and/or extreme flood risk were less likely to bid on the home if they had information about the home's property risk.
Ìý
Access to insurance coverage is a critical function of resilience. Insurance transfers the risk of loss allowing people to more quickly and fully recover from significant loss events. Residual market mechanisms provide a means to allow access to insurance coverage in challenging property insurance markets where coverage may be otherwise constrained. Market constraints can occur for various reasons, including, but not limited to, natural disasters. It is not uncommon for the number of policies written in residual markets and insurers of last resort to increase following severe weather events. Not all states have residual markets or insurers of last resort. Residual markets are sometimes called involuntary market programs, Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plans, Beach and Windstorm Plans.
WAYS TO GET INVOLVED
, enacted in 2022, requires the Insurance Commissioner to conduct a study and prepare a report on methods to address the stability, availability, and affordability of homeowner's insurance in Colorado with a focus on stabilizing the market.
Many states already have residual market mechanisms in place. The list below is not exhaustive of all programs in place across the country and is limited to property coverage.
The provides basic fire insurance coverage for properties unable to secure coverage in the private market.
The provides property insurance when coverage is not otherwise available through a standard insurance company or excess and surplus lines broker.
is the state property insurer of last resort.
is a non-profit organization to provide insurance products for residential and commercial property as the state insurer of last resort.
also known as the Massachusetts FAIR Plan provides basic property insurance on eligible property for applicants unable to obtain coverage through the voluntary market.
Mississippi has several residual market plans available as markets of last resort.
is an association of insurance companies licensed to write property insurance coverage in North Carolina, created as an market of last resort for basic property insurance.
is also an association of insurance companies licensed to write property insurance coverage in North Carolina, established as an insurer of last resort for property in the beach and coastal areas of the state.
The is the provides coverage for wind and hail property insurance in the coastal area of the state to homes and businesses unable to obtain coverage through the standard insurance market.
provides windstorm and hail insurance along the Texas coastline.